In customer experience (CX) design, much attention goes to creating journeys that attract, delight, and drive satisfaction. But what about experiences where users don’t have a choice—interactions they’re required to engage in, even if they’d rather not? These high-stakes, involuntary experiences are crucial and often regulated, presenting unique challenges for CX designers.

These “involuntary experiences” span scenarios from government compliance tasks to essential health services, insurance claims, and regulatory obligations. Such interactions require a different approach, focusing not on delight but on transparency, efficiency, and empathy.

To understand the varying degrees of choice in customer experiences, let's consider the "The Involuntary Experience Spectrum":

Customer experiences can be viewed along a spectrum—from high choice and low essentiality to low choice and high essentiality. Involuntary experiences fall at the high-essentiality end, where mandatory interactions necessitate a design approach that prioritises clarity, support, and respect. Whether it’s applying for Centrelink benefits, navigating tax compliance, or making an insurance claim (often perceived as a grudge purchase), these high-stakes experiences demand an understanding of unique user needs and challenges.

Unique Challenges of High-Stakes, Involuntary Experiences

Traditional CX design, with its focus on choice and satisfaction, falls short for involuntary experiences due to inherent challenges that require organisations to adapt across their service, operations, and digital offerings:

• Lack of Motivation: Users are often unmotivated to engage, making it essential to design for clarity, efficiency, and simplicity to keep them engaged and informed.
• Heightened Emotions: Anxiety, frustration, or fear may be prevalent in high-stakes interactions, requiring a focus on empathy, reassurance, and psychological safety.
• Power Imbalance: Users may feel disempowered, highlighting the need for transparency, respect, and a sense of control.

These interactions are not just transactional; they are often deeply personal and complex, demanding a strategic approach that goes beyond user experience and extends into service delivery and operational resilience.

Why Invest in Involuntary Experiences?

For many organisations, it’s tempting to ask why resources should be invested in improving experiences that are mandatory. The answer lies in the transformative impact of even small CX improvements:

• Reduced Friction, Increased Efficiency: Streamlining processes and enhancing clarity reduce confusion, lead to faster completion times, fewer errors, and a more efficient experience for users and providers alike. Operational efficiencies also lower costs and improve service resilience.
• Enhanced Well-being: By integrating empathy and support, these experiences can be less stressful for users, fostering dignity and respect in high-stakes scenarios.
• Strengthened Relationships: Positive interactions, even in mandatory contexts, build trust and goodwill, encouraging future loyalty and a reputation for empathy.
• Improved Public Perception and Brand Differentiation: Organisations that demonstrate user-centric design in high-stakes situations set themselves apart, fostering trust and a reputation for empathy that resonates with users and stakeholders.
• Tangible ROI: Investment in optimised service delivery for involuntary experiences yields returns through cost savings, operational efficiencies, and better employee morale.

Evaluating the impact

The success of high-stakes, involuntary interactions extends beyond customer satisfaction. It’s measured by how effectively these interactions meet critical organisational and user goals, offering meaningful outcomes across three key dimensions:

• Service Effectiveness: Assess how well current service models support users in high-stakes situations. Identify pain points, measure response times, and ensure services meet regulatory standards without sacrificing user support.
• Operational Efficiency: Optimise internal operations for managing high-stakes interactions to improve resource allocation and reduce costs. Evaluating process bottlenecks, efficiency metrics, and cost-saving opportunities reveals the true impact of operational excellence.
• User Perception and Experience: Understand how customers perceive these interactions—are they clear, supportive, and respectful? Gathering user feedback provides valuable insights to refine processes, reduce friction, and strengthen trust in future interactions.

By examining these perspectives, organisations can align their service delivery strategies, operations, and customer experiences to meet the demands of high-stakes interactions effectively.

The Opportunity

In an environment where high-stakes, involuntary interactions are essential, organisations have a unique opportunity to transform mandatory experiences into positive touchpoints. By prioritising service effectiveness, operational excellence, and empathetic experience design, organisations can foster trust, enhance public value, and deliver consistent, impactful outcomes.

This approach goes beyond customer experience enhancement; it provides a strategic framework that integrates service delivery, operational efficiency, and user-centred design. By addressing high-stakes interactions holistically, organisations can turn these moments into opportunities for connection, differentiation, and lasting impact.

Interested in learning more?

‍